Nov 13,2026
The last article in the series, and the question we get asked most. Ten questions, one score, four options with prices — including the three cases where a $400 curtain beats a $9,000 cabin.
An enclosure does three jobs, and they are separable. It blocks the direct beam and specular reflections (safety). It contains fume (air quality). It keeps bystanders out of the working radius (procedure). A cabin does all three; a curtain does the first and third; extraction does the second.
That is why "do I need an enclosure" is the wrong question. The right one is: which of the three jobs is my workshop failing at?
Answer yes or no. The score at the end maps to a recommendation in Table 3.
Q1Are other people working within 3 m of the beam path? Bystanders are 13% of our eye incidents and 100% of the ones nobody expected.
Q2Do you clean polished, reflective metal? A specular reflection is a second beam, and it does not stop at 3 m.
Q3Are there walkways, doors or vehicle routes behind the work area? People arrive without warning; a beam does not.
Q4Do you clean painted, oiled or galvanised parts? Fume, not light, is the long-term hazard here.
Q5Is the workspace shared with welding, grinding or assembly? Sparks and dust travel; so does reflected light.
Q6Do visitors or customers walk through the shop? A signed area is a legal control; a wall is a physical one.
Q7Is the machine used by more than one operator, on different shifts? Consistency of procedure drops with headcount.
Q8Do you run above 1000 W for more than two hours a day? Higher power, longer exposure, wider hazard distance.
Q9Is there a legal or customer audit requirement (ISO 45001, customer site audit)? Auditors want to see a physical barrier, not a floor marking.
Q10Has anyone been flashed, startled or burned in the last 12 months? One incident is a data point; two is a design problem.
Prices below are what our customers actually paid in 2025–2026, not list prices. Option 1 is what most shops should start with; option 4 is for production cells, not job shops.
| Option | What it is | Blocks beam | Contains fume | Typical cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Curtain + floor marking | OD-rated laser curtain on a track, 2 × 3 m, plus taped area and signage | Yes | No | $380–$650 |
| 2. Curtain + extraction | Option 1 plus a fume arm or portable extractor at the work face | Yes | Yes | $900–$1,600 |
| 3. Modular cabin | Panelled booth, interlocked door, viewing window, extraction port | Yes | Yes | $4,500–$9,000 |
| 4. Integrated cell | Cabinet machine with Class 1 access, turntable, robotic arm | Yes | Yes | $18,000+ |
Table 1 — Four enclosure options. The gap between option 2 and option 3 is mostly about interlocked doors and auditable paperwork, not about light.
| Score | What it means | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|
| 0–2 | Single operator, rough surfaces, isolated bay | Eyewear + floor marking is enough |
| 3–5 | Shared space, some reflective work, occasional visitors | Option 1 or 2 — curtain, not cabin |
| 6–8 | Multiple operators, fume, audits | Option 2 minimum; option 3 if audited |
| 9–10 | Production cell, high power, walkways behind | Option 3 or 4 — a cabin is the only defensible answer |
Table 2 — Score to recommendation. The threshold at 6 is where "we will be careful" stops being an acceptable control.
A laser curtain is OD-rated fabric on a track. It stops the beam completely, it can be moved, and it costs less than a day of lost production. For a job shop cleaning mixed parts in a shared bay, it solves the safety problem and leaves the fume problem to an extractor — which you probably need anyway.
What a curtain does not do is survive an audit that asks for an interlock. If your customer requires ISO 45001 evidence or your insurer asks how the beam is contained when the door opens, you need option 3, and no amount of curtain will substitute.
| Feature | Curtain (opt. 2) | Cabin (opt. 3) |
|---|---|---|
| Blocks direct beam and reflections | Yes | Yes |
| Interlocked door stops the beam | No | Yes |
| Fume contained at source | Partly | Yes |
| Auditable for ISO 45001 / customer audit | Rarely | Yes |
| Noise reduction | 3–5 dB | 12–18 dB |
| Moves with the machine | Yes | No |
| Cost | $900–$1,600 | $4,500–$9,000 |
Table 3 — What the extra $4,000 buys. Two features matter: the interlock and the audit trail. The rest is comfort.
Score the ten questions. Below 3, eyewear and marking are enough. Between 3 and 5, buy a curtain. Above 6, buy a cabin — and if you answered yes to the bystander, reflection and incident questions, treat the score as 6 no matter what the total says.
Six of ten buyers need $400 of curtain, not $9,000 of cabin. The other four need the cabin, and they usually know it already — they are asking for permission, not information.